Posted by Jan (220.127.116.11) on July 02, 2003 at 02:50:46:
In Reply to: Freud's Narcissist Revisited posted by Charlie (18.104.22.168) on July 01, 2003 at 21:23:20:
> A new book just came out called The Productive Narcissist: The promise and perils of visionary leadership, written by a psychoanalyst Dr. Malcovy. I was wondering if any of you were familiar with it. Basically, skipping through all the personal analogies which keeps the book thick, it was a quick read.
> He reinterprets Freud's Narcissist type, saying basically that a narcissist embodies two traits simultaneously, which are 1) a rejection of the status quo and 2) a need to change the world. From those two present traits, he explains what traits result as either strengths or weaknesses when it comes to leadership--i.e. vision, passion, motivation, emotional insensivity, individuality, thirst for knowledge, strategic thinking, risktaking, extreme perseverance, grandiosity, etc--that emerge as part of the narcissist's repertoire. Then he uses examples of past leaders and visionaries--from political, to business, to arts, etc...to show how their behaviors fit into this paradigm. And he also talks about Freud's theory on the narcissist's usual parental orientation--a weak, sometimes absent, underachieving father and a strong, supportive mother, and then goes on to show parallels in many of those leaders' childhoods.
> What interested me was Freud's personality types--the erotic, the obsessive, the marketing, and the narcissist--and that Freud did not view narcissism as a pathological disorder as it is viewed today. Although there are only four types here, they make a lot of sense to me when I read about Freuds descriptions of them, and how they perceive the world in different ways. Obviously, mainstream psychology has rejected them for why I don't know. Probably because they are too broad. Maybe you know more than I do about that subject. Anyhow, I thought I would share this with you and get some reactions.
+++ Dear Charlie,
From my memory:
erotic = > Millon's histrionic type
obsessive = > Millon's compulsive type
narcissist => Millon's narcissistic type
marketing => ?
Millon (and popularizer Oldham) builds on the psychological tradition and doesn't reject it.
Post a Followup